The Landmark Case That Recognizes Data's True Value
Italy's unprecedented VAT claim against Meta, X, and LinkedIn marks a watershed moment in digital taxation policy. By claiming €887.6 million from Meta, €12.5 million from X, and around €140 million from LinkedIn, Italian tax authorities have officially recognized that personal data has immense monetary value.We wholeheartedly agree with this assessment.Italy's position that free user registrations should be treated as taxable transactions—because they involve exchanging membership access for personal data—finally acknowledges an economic reality that has been hiding in plain sight.
The Hidden Economy of Personal Data
For too long, Big Tech has operated under the fiction that their services are "free." Users sign up for social media accounts, search engines, and digital platforms without paying cash, but they're paying something far more valuable—their personal data. This data becomes the foundation for trillion-dollar advertising empires, sophisticated behavioral profiling, and algorithmic manipulation of user behavior.The numbers speak for themselves. Meta's revenue per user continues to grow year over year, reaching new heights as the company refines its ability to extract value from user data. Every click, scroll, like, and share contributes to detailed behavioral profiles that advertisers pay premium prices to access. X monetizes user engagement and data for targeted advertising, while LinkedIn transforms professional information into a lucrative recruitment and B2B marketing platform.These companies have built their business models on harvesting, processing, and monetizing personal information at unprecedented scale. The Italian tax authorities are simply calling it what it is: a commercial transaction with real monetary value.
The Problem: Users Lack Control Over Their Own Data
While we applaud Italy's recognition of data's monetary worth, the VAT approach only addresses the taxation side of a much deeper problem. The fundamental issue remains: users have surrendered control over their personal data to centralized platforms that profit from this information without user oversight or meaningful consent.This creates a problematic dynamic where:
- Users provide their personal data with limited understanding of how it will be used
- Big Tech processes and monetizes this data for massive profits
- Users receive nothing but "free" services that come at the cost of their privacy
- Privacy becomes a luxury rather than a fundamental right
zkMe's Vision: Self-Sovereign Identity Infrastructure
At zkMe, we believe the solution goes far beyond taxation. Rather than simply ensuring governments collect their share of Big Tech's data profits, we need to fundamentally restructure how personal data is controlled and monetized. We envision a future where users maintain true ownership over their identity data through Self-Sovereign Identity frameworks.Our approach fundamentally changes the relationship between users, their data, and the platforms that seek to use it:
Identity Oracles and Zero-Knowledge Proofs
Through our Identity Oracle infrastructure, users generate proof of their credentials anonymously using Zero-Knowledge Proof (ZKP) and Multi-Party Computations (MPC) technology. Unlike centralized platforms that aggregate user data for their own benefit, zkMe enables users to prove specific claims (age, citizenship, accreditation status, etc.) without revealing underlying sensitive information. No platform or service provider ever gains access to raw personal data.
Privacy-Preserving Compliance
Our zero-knowledge proof solutions, including zkKYC compliance suite and Anti-Sybil suite, enable businesses to meet regulatory requirements without the massive data collection that fuels surveillance capitalism. Companies can verify user eligibility for services while users keep their personal data completely private—eliminating the false choice between compliance and privacy.
User-Centric Value Framework
Our infrastructure is designed with users at the center of value creation. Through our XP system, we recognize user participation in the identity verification ecosystem, creating a foundation that positions users to benefit from the network effects they help generate. This approach establishes the groundwork for sustainable user incentives that align with long-term network growth.
A Privacy-First Digital Economy
The Italian VAT case represents an important first step toward recognizing the true economic value of personal data. However, taxation alone doesn't address the fundamental need for users to regain control over their digital identities.zkMe's Self-Sovereign Identity approach offers a more comprehensive solution:
- Users maintain data ownership rather than surrendering it to platforms
- Privacy is preserved through zero-knowledge proofs instead of being sacrificed for "free" services
- Compliance is maintained without compromising decentralization or user rights
- Users are positioned as stakeholders in the value they help create rather than being excluded from digital economies built on their data
- Data sovereignty is restored to individual users rather than being controlled by corporate intermediaries
The Path Forward
Italy's bold stance against Big Tech's data extraction should be applauded and adopted across the European Union and beyond. But we shouldn't stop at taxation. The ultimate goal should be creating digital infrastructure that empowers users to control their own data and benefit from its value.As the Web3 ecosystem matures, we have the opportunity to build alternatives to the surveillance capitalism model that has dominated the internet for the past two decades. Through Self-Sovereign Identity, zero-knowledge proofs, and user-controlled frameworks, we can create a digital economy that serves everyone—not just Big Tech shareholders.The Italian tax case may force companies like Meta, X, and LinkedIn to pay their fair share to governments. But the bigger prize is ensuring that users—the true creators of this valuable data—regain control over their digital identities.zkMe is building the infrastructure for a privacy-first, user-sovereign digital economy.
Learn more about our solutions at zk.me or explore our documentation to see how Self-Sovereign Identity can transform your platform's approach to user data and compliance.
About zkMe
⭐ zkMe builds web3 protocols and infrastructure for compliant, self-sovereign, and private verification of user credentials. The only web3-native solution for dApps to fulfill user due diligence (KYC) in zero-knowledge natively onchain, without compromises on the decentralization & privacy ethos of web3.
🔖 Use Cases: zkKYC, zk Credit Score, zk GPS Geoblocking, zk Investor Accreditation, Onchain AML, Anti-Bot/Sybil Protection.
🚀Trusted by over 80 projects and with over 1.5 million user credentials, backed by Multicoin Capital, OKX Ventures, Robot Ventures and more. zkMe is the leading onchain compliance provider.
For more information, follow the links below:
Website | Twitter | Discord | Telegram | Telegram Mini app |
